City Cast Philly logo

How To Recycle Your Old Pumpkins

Posted on November 8, 2023   |   Updated on September 30, 2025
City Cast Philly staff

City Cast Philly staff

When your jack-o'-lantern has seen better days. (Getty/Credit:luvmakphoto)

When your jack-o'-lantern has seen better days. (Getty/Credit:luvmakphoto)

As we transition from spooky szn into the gauntlet of winter holidays (please note: it is indeed far too early to play All I Want For Christmas Is You, sorry) Halloween revelers in Philadelphia are running into a squishy, soggy problem: rotting pumpkins. Instead of embracing your inner Billy Corgan and smashing those gourds, here’s some options for reusing or disposing of your old pumpkins, many courtesy of Pennsylvania Resources Council.

Whole, Undecorated Pumpkins

You can still eat these! They may have been sold as “carving” pumpkins, but they are perfectly edible. You can use them in soups and other hearty dishes, or even make a pumpkin milkshake. Or, for the beauty-inclined, the PRC also has a recipe for a pumpkin pulp facemask (technically edible).

Carved Pumpkins

If you already compost, you can smash them up and add them to your bin — just be sure to take the seeds out so they don’t sprout. Or, you can leave them in the woods for wildlife.

Pumpkin Guts

You don’t want these in your compost, but you can pick out the seeds and roast them for a zero-waste snack.

Painted or Decorated Pumpkins

If you cut off the decorated parts, you can dispose of these like you would the carved ones.

🎃 And if none of these options work, you can roll the dice, stick them in your yard (if you have one) and hope the squirrels/rats take it from there.

H/t to Hey Pittsburgh newsletter editor Francesca Dabecco for some of these ideas!

Share article

Hey Philly

Stay connected to City Cast Philly and get ready to join the local conversation.

Can't subscribe? Turn off your ad blocker and try again.

Urban Almanac

See All
Urban AlmanacSeptember 17, 2024

When Will We Start To See Philly’s Fall Colors?

The fall foliage in Philly and the rest of Pennsylvania is beautiful. But when is the best time to see it?

Students walking on Locust Walk at the University of Pennsylvania, underneath trees with leaves of orange, yellow, and green.
Urban AlmanacAugust 20, 2024

How to Make Your Own Air Purifier

Air purifiers can be expensive, but you can make your own at home with a few simple items. What an inexpensive and easy way to ensure you...

The components of a homemade air purifier.
Urban AlmanacAugust 13, 2024

How Turning Out the Lights Can Prevent Bird Deaths

The “Lights Out Philly” initiative looks to reduce the number of birds that die from striking glass windows and buildings during migratio...

Philly at nighttime.
Urban AlmanacJuly 30, 2024

How Philly’s Public Green Space Measures Up Nationally

In 2024, Philly scored a 57.5 on the Trust for Public Land’s ParkScore index. Access was a strength, while investment was a liability.

Volunteers tend to a park.
Urban AlmanacJuly 16, 2024

How Beavers Went from Eradication to Abundance in Pennsylvania

Have you ever seen a beaver in Philadelphia?

A close-up photo of a beaver.
Urban AlmanacJuly 2, 2024

How the Urban Heat Island Effect Impacts Philly

This summer has already shattered temperature records across the country. Here’s why it’s extra hot in Philadelphia.

A dog walking underneath a fire hydrant spraying water.
Urban AlmanacJune 25, 2024

Free Sunscreen Now Available in PA State Parks

Pennsylvania has expanded its free sunscreen program this season to 52 of its 124 state parks.

A sign giving directions at Nolde Forest Environmental Education Center.
Urban AlmanacMay 14, 2024

What Makes Rocks in the Wissahickon Sparkle

Throughout my many hiking ventures in Northwest Philly's Wissahickon Valley Park, I always seem to admire shiny rocks along the trails an...

A river runs through tree-emblazoned scene of shiny rocks.

The latest in Philly

Sponsored

Moving to Philadelphia? What to Check Before You Pick a Neighborhood, Book a Truck, and Sign a Lease

With this guide, you can move to Philadelphia, move from another place to Philadelphia, or just see if living in Philadelphia fits your d...

Wellknown Moving Company Logo
Keep It LocalOctober 29

Where to Buy Last-Minute Halloween Costumes Around Philly

Rent a costume in Northeast Philly, find DIY supplies at a creative reuse warehouse, or shop 30,000 horror items at ScarePros in Bucks Co...

 A mannequin dressed as a scary clown with bright red hair, a snarling white face, a red-and-white striped shirt, and blood-stained yellow overalls stands inside ScarePros Halloween & Horror surrounded by masks, costumes, accessories, and boxed decorations.
Food & DrinkOctober 29

Your Guide to New Restaurants, Bars & Cafés in Philly

Philly’s culinary scene is constantly growing and changing. Here’s a recap of some of the restaurants, bars, cafés, and other delicious s...

A top-down view of a spread of food on a bright red table, including pan-fried dumplings, a salad, and roasted chicken with sauces.
Keep It LocalOctober 29

Spooky Quiz: How Well Do You Know Philadelphia’s Haunted History?

Think you know Philadelphia’s spookiest haunts? Take our Halloween quiz and find out.

A brick Philadelphia building decorated for Halloween with black cobwebs around arched windows, a witch holding a broom, a skeleton figure beneath an orange jack-o’-lantern, silver gargoyle statues, pumpkins, and a hanging ghost along the sidewalk.
Philly, ExplainedOctober 23

Play Our Philly Crossword Puzzle

This mini-crossword is filled with clues on Philly history and headlines.

City Cast Philly Crossword
Keep It LocalOctober 22

Where to Pick Up a Pumpkin in Philly (and Beyond)

For the city pumpkin patch experience: Cityside Pumpkin Patch has turned Liberty Point on the Penn’s Landing waterfront into a pumpkin-fi...

Two children sit on a pile of large orange pumpkins on the ground of Morris Arboretum & Gardens. Behind them, several people admire scarecrows along the scarecrow walk.
Keep It LocalOctober 22

Your Guide to Shopping Philly’s Farmers Markets (Almost) All Week Long

There’s a farmers market in Philadelphia for nearly every day of the week, from a midweek stop in Old City to a Sunday stroll through Soc...

Vendors under pop-up tents, including Lost Bread Co., are set up at Rittenhouse Square while people shop.
Local CivicsOctober 20

Your Philly Guide to Voter Guides in November 2026

Here are some resources to help you learn about the people and measures on your ballot.

"vote" pins