City Cast Philly logo
Advertisement image

What’s the Deal With the Curse of Billy Penn?

Posted on November 29, 2022   |   Updated on September 30, 2025
Brittany Valentine

Brittany Valentine

Billy Penn statue on top of City Hall. (Peter Gridley/Getty Images)

Billy Penn statue on top of City Hall. (Peter Gridley/Getty Images)

If there’s one thing I love about cities in general, it’s urban legends. Philly has a very interesting one, and of course, it has to do with sports. Ever heard of “The Curse of Billy Penn?”  

Here’s how the story goes. Once upon a time, Philadelphia sports teams were on fire. In 1967 the Sixers became NBA champs. In 1974 and 1975 the Flyers won the Stanley Cup. Five years later, the Phillies won the World Series. Then the Sixers became champions again in 1983. The golden era, if you will.  

But in 1987, developer Willard Rouse erected One Liberty Place which soared past the William Penn statue by about 400 feet. What’s the big deal with that? Well, throughout the 20th century there was a “gentlemen’s agreement” among developers to keep any building from rising higher than the top of Billy Penn.  

Is Willard Rouse the reason that Philly sports teams lost their mojo? That’s what the legend says! Weirdly enough, later that same year the Flyers lost to the Edmonton Oilers in the seventh game of the Stanley Cup finals and then lost the finals again a decade later.

Phillies fans cheering on their team in the 2022 World Series championship games. (Daniel Shirey /Getty Images)

Phillies fans cheering on their team in the 2022 World Series championship games. (Daniel Shirey /Getty Images)

That’s not all though. Our beloved teams suffered a series of losses from 1993 to 2005. Fans experienced the devastation of losing the World Series, the Super Bowl, and the NBA Finals.  

At some point during all this defeat, someone put the pieces together and theorized that the angry spirit of William Penn must be the cause.  

Does this urban legend still hold true? I mean, look at what happened with the Phillies in October. Looks like Billy Penn is holding a grudge.

Share article

Hey Philly

Stay connected to City Cast Philly and get ready to join the local conversation.

Can't subscribe? Turn off your ad blocker and try again.
Advertisement image

The latest in Philly

Sponsored

Moving to Philadelphia? What to Check Before You Pick a Neighborhood, Book a Truck, and Sign a Lease

With this guide, you can move to Philadelphia, move from another place to Philadelphia, or just see if living in Philadelphia fits your d...

Wellknown Moving Company Logo
Philly, ExplainedOctober 9

Play Our Philly Crossword Puzzle

This mini-crossword is filled with clues on Philly history and headlines.

City Cast Philly Crossword
Keep It LocalOctober 8

4 Places To Get Very, Very Scared in Philly

Get chased through a “Terrifier” filming site, wander a former prison after dark, or hunt ghosts along the Manayunk Canal at these four f...

On a foggy night, a man dressed in all black, wearing a top hat, and holding a cane faces the Lincoln Mill Haunted House in Manayunk, a former textile mill. A police car with its lights on is parked in front of the brick building.
Keep It LocalOctober 8

Philly Spooky Quiz: How Well Do You Know Eastern State Penitentiary?

Over 100 inmates escaped Eastern State, but can you name its most famous? Put your Philly history to the test before your next eerie visi...

The imposing Gothic stone facade of Eastern State Penitentiary in Philadelphia, with its castle-like turret, arched iron gate entrance, and weathered dark stone walls.
Philly HistoryOctober 5

What’s Philly’s Connection to Edgar Allan Poe?

The “The Tell-Tale Heart” author lived in several homes in the city, but only one remains to this day.

A mural on a brick wall depicting a portrait of Edgar Allan Poe against a blue background in an oval frame. He is wearing a black dress coat and tie, and white shirt. Beside him is a quote from his short story Hop-Frog: “ I never knew anyone so keenly alive to joke as the king was. He seemed to live only for joking. To tell a good story of the joke kind, and to tell it well, was the surest road to his favor.”
Philly, ExplainedOctober 2

Prove Your Weekly Philly Knowledge

How well do you know Philly's latest headlines and historical facts? Try your hand at this quiz to find out!

A rainy view of South Broad Street at a traffic triangle. Several cars drive on the moist street under a cloudy sky.
Philly's BestOctober 2

How to Spend October 2026 in Philly

Mark your calendars with these frights and delights. This month, visit Philly’s pumpkin patches and haunted houses, or explore the city o...

Text that says “Halloween Nights at Eastern State Penitentiary” is projected onto the stone facade of the Neo-Gothic prison. Light emits from inside the building as guests enter through the main doorway.
Keep It LocalOctober 1

Where to Spend a Cozy Fall Afternoon in Philly

Looking for a warm, cozy place to enjoy an autumn afternoon? Here are four spots in Philly sure to give you maximum coziness.

Interior of Eremita Cafe in Roxborough, with customers sitting at tables and vintage upholstered chairs beneath a pressed-tin ceiling. A colorful abstract mural covers the left wall, while framed artwork lines the opposite wall and tall windows fill the space with natural light.