City Cast Philly logo

What’s The Deal With The Eastern State Penitentiary?

Posted on October 18, 2022   |   Updated on September 30, 2025
Brittany Valentine

Brittany Valentine

Sometimes real life is scarier than a haunted house attraction. (catnap72/Getty Images)

Sometimes real life is scarier than a haunted house attraction. (catnap72/Getty Images)

The Eastern State Penitentiary is one of Philly’s spookiest spots and hosts an annual haunted house attraction during the Halloween season. But how many of us actually know the history of this site? 

The penitentiary opened in 1829 and was known for its experimental and controversial system of total isolation of prisoners.  

Inmates were required to wear hoods whenever supervisors moved them around the building. To reduce the cost of incarceration, the state had prisoners do work in the cells like shoemaking, weaving, and chair caning.  


The only visitors ever allowed were members of the prison society or a local minister employed by the penitentiary known as a “moral instructor.”  


Critics at the time claimed that this type of treatment leads to insanity and even death.  

One of the most prominent critics was novelist Charles Dickens. Dickens visited the prison in 1842 and argued in his book “American Notes” that while the intentions were human, the system itself was torturous.  

There’s so much more history to dive into, but even after learning just a bit one does start to question the ethics of using sites like prisons, hospitals, and asylums as Halloween attractions.

see more:education

Share article

Hey Philly

Stay connected to City Cast Philly and get ready to join the local conversation.

Can't subscribe? Turn off your ad blocker and try again.

Philly, Explained

See All

The latest in Philly

Sponsored

Moving to Philadelphia? What to Check Before You Pick a Neighborhood, Book a Truck, and Sign a Lease

With this guide, you can move to Philadelphia, move from another place to Philadelphia, or just see if living in Philadelphia fits your d...

Wellknown Moving Company Logo
Food & DrinkJune 4

Grab Summer Produce at These Farmers Markets

It’s the time of year to start stocking up on summer favorites like berries. Find the freshest crops at your local market.

Boxes of blueberries, raspberries, and blackberries
Philly's BestJune 2

How to Spend June 2026 in Philly

Wander Philly’s museums, pick fresh fruit, and celebrate the solstice throughout the month.

Drummers perform in Old City during Pride March
Philly Life HacksJune 2

Where To Take Swimming Lessons in Philly

Don’t just sit poolside all summer. Learn to splash in the water safely by taking these foundational swim classes.

Swimmer does a lap in a pool
Philly HistoryJune 1

The First Successful Sit-In for LGBTQ+ Rights Was in Philadelphia

The act of civil disobedience against discrimination occurred before the more widely known Stonewall Riots, which are considered the cata...

A marker at the former 17th Street location of Dewey’s stands at 219 S. 17th St. (Siani Colón / City Cast Philly)
Food & DrinkMay 28

Your Guide to New Restaurants, Bars and Cafés in Philly

Philly’s local culinary scene is constantly growing and changing. Here’s a recap of some of the restaurants, bars, cafés, and other delic...

Bowls of loaded jacket potatoes
Philly's BestMay 21

Ride a Bike and Make a Friend at These Philly Biking Clubs

Why bike solo when you can join a community that also loves exploring the city on two wheels?

Zoomed in shot of yellow bicycle and its spokes
Philly HistoryMay 19

Who Is Ona ‘Oney’ Judge?

A new holiday honors one woman’s brave escape to freedom even as there are efforts to erase that history.

Names on a stone wall: Austin, Paris, Hercules, Christopher Sheels, Richmond, Giles, Oney Judge, Moll, Joe